Mystery Horror Movie Reviews

Looking for a new Mystery horror movie to watch, but don't want to waste your time sitting through a movie you'll hate? You're in luck! We built AllHorror specifically to help you find the horror movies you're most likely to love. Check out our spoiler-free "Worth Watching" reviews below. All reviews are short and written to give you an idea of what kind of Mystery movie it is and what other Mystery movies it's similar to, just so you know what to expect. And nearly all Mystery movie reviews include videos from other reviewers, so you get multiple opinions from the horror community.

Fear of Rain (2021) Review

A girl living with schizophrenia struggles with terrifying hallucinations as she begins to suspect her neighbor has kidnapped a child. The only person who believes her is Caleb -a boy she isn't even sure exists. Fear of Rain was directed by Ca...

July 03rd, 2021 | , | Horror Genre: , ,

Dead & Buried (1981) Review

After a series of gory murders by mobs of townspeople against visiting tourists, the corpses begin to come back to life. Dead & Buried was directed by Gary Sherman (also known for Poltergeist III) and stars James Farentino (from Violent Midnight),...

June 29th, 2021 | , | Horror Genre: , , ,

Madhouse (2004) Review

It’s about a madhouse – in which the patients might be saner than it seems. Madhouse was the directorial debut of William Butler (Gingerdead Man 3 and Black Velvet Pantsuit) who also wrote the screenplay. It stars Joshua Leonard (The Blair Wit...

June 15th, 2021 | , | Horror Genre: , , , ,

Blood Moon (2021) Review

As the locals begin to probe, Esme must battle to protect her son and a terrifying secret before the next full moon threatens their very existence. Blood Moon was directed by Emma Tammi (known for The Wind) and stars Megalyn Echikunwoke, Yonas Kib...

June 09th, 2021 | , | Horror Genre: , , ,

Lighthouse Keeper (2016) Review

It's about a guy marooned on a remote peninsula with nothing but an old lighthouse keeper, a sexy hermitess and some salty ghosts to keep him company. Lighthouse Keeper was directed by Benjamin Cooper (who also directed The Brink) and star...

November 27th, 2019 | , | Horror Genre: , , , ,

Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2 (2000) Review

It's about a group of people on a Blair Witch tour who get the firsthand experience they were after, and immediately regret it. Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2 was directed by Joe Berlinger (who also directed Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil ...

Apostle (2018) Review

It's about a guy who travels to a remote island to rescue his sister from a cult. Apostle was directed by Gareth Evans and stars Dan Stevens, Michael Sheen (from Underworld) and Lucy Boynton (from Don't Knock Twice).  Your God Can...

December 06th, 2018 | , | Horror Genre: , , , ,

The Wicker Man Review (1973)

It’s about a policeman who visits a secluded island to investigate the disappearance of a child, only to discover that the island is a Pagan cult. The Wicker Man was directed by Robin Hardy (who also directed The Fantasist and The Wicker Tree) a...

October 30th, 2018 | , | Horror Genre: , , , ,

Mulholland Drive Review (2001)

It’s about a woman with amnesia stumbling through the seedy underbelly of modern Hollywood. Mulholland Drive was directed by David Lynch (who also directed Lost Highway and Blue Velvet) and stars Naomi Watts (from Funny Games), Laura Harring (fr...

September 14th, 2018 | , | Horror Genre: , , , ,

The Birds Review (1963)

It’s about socialite citizens in California witnessing the advent of birds attacking all humanity. The Birds was directed by Alfred Hitchcock (who also directed Psycho and Strangers on a Train) and stars Rod Taylor, Tippi Hedren  and  Jessica ...

June 29th, 2018 | , | Horror Genre: , , , ,

Bela Kiss Prologue Review (2013)

It’s about a group of amateur bank robbers who hold out at a swanky, but mysterious, hotel only to learn its caretakers are more threatening than the law. Bela Kiss: Prologue  was directed by  Lucien Förstner  and stars  Kristina Klebe (fro...

June 17th, 2018 | , | Horror Genre: , , , , ,

Would it Kill You to Subscribe?

Get horror news, reviews and movie recommendations every Friday!

We respect your email privacy