Pillow Party Massacre (2023) Review

Spoiler-free so you can read before you watch

Pillow Party Massacre (2023) Review

Horrorific content by adrian on June 22nd, 2023 | Movie Review | Slasher, Cabin in the Woods, Killer, Campy, Mystery, Maniac, B-Horror

Add Pillow Party Massacre (2023) to your Watchlist

Add to Watchlist

You need to login or register to add this movie to your horror watchlist.

It's about four former high school friends who reconnect at a vacation home where a maniacal killer stalks the night, which may be connected to the tragic end to a bullying accident that occurred years earlier.

Pillow Party Massacre was directed by Calvin Morie McCarthy and stars Laura WelshNeil Green (Exorcism in Utero (2023)), Jax KellingtonJon MeggisonAmy DiLorenzoStephanie Leet, Steve Larkin, Calvin Morie McCarthy (Exorcism in Utero), John Reddy, and Allegra Sweeney (Exorcism in Utero).

Pillow Party Massacre Review

Pillow Party Massacre aims to capture the essence of classic 80s slasher films, with scantily clad heroines fighting for survival against a masked killer in a secluded cabin. While the film starts to gain momentum once the murders begin, a disappointing final act and revelation undermine the potential for a moderately satisfying nostalgic horror thriller.

The story revolves around friends reuniting two years after a disastrous April Fools' prank. The Panther Squad, consisting of Sam, Miles, Alana, Barb, and Mikki, played a prank on their friend Ash by humiliating her with a fake make-out session. However, Ash's reaction lands her in prison.

Two years later, during their college summer break, the Panther Squad decides to spend a weekend together in the woods. While Sam is more aware of their role in Ash's unfortunate fate, the others try to push aside their guilt, believing that there's nothing they can do now. Adding to the suspense, there is an escape from a nearby prison, and the mention of an escaped mental hospital patient heightens the horror movie atmosphere. Unfortunately, the characters' self-aware commentary on horror movie scenarios falls flat and needs more cleverness than the filmmakers intended.

Director and screenwriter Calvin Morie McCarthy demonstrate an apparent affection for the genre, adhering closely to predictable yet expected tropes. McCarthy delivers on the essential elements but fails to sustain them effectively throughout the film's short duration. The film suffers from weak dialogue and questionable character choices, often defying basic horror movie logic.

To its credit, Pillow Party Massacre lives up to its title with an unnecessary but visually appealing slow-motion, topless pillow fight. Given the film's title, there is no need to demand high-level horror, and McCarthy embraces the film's B-movie concept.

Surprisingly, the performances in this low-budget horror film are primarily decent. However, the portrayal of the killer is the weakest, ultimately hindering the effectiveness of the final act.

The soundtrack heavily relies on 80s synth-pop despite the film being set in the modern era, where cell phones struggle with a reception in the mountains.

McCarthy frequently employs the killer's point of view in the cinematography, but this approach becomes tiresome, especially paired with heavy Darth Vader-like breathing.

Some decent kill scenes manage to compensate for the film's limited budget. These scenes successfully capture the spirit of inspired 80s slasher films, although some practical effects appear dated.

Unfortunately, McCarthy's decision to incorporate CGI kills proves to be a poor choice, as the effects come across as cheap and low-budget. This detracts from Montgomery's commendable attempt to diversify the kills due to cost limitations.

One significant problem is McCarthy's struggle to find effective camera angles, resulting in disorienting scenes that could have been improved with better direction.

Another annoyance is the killer's inconsistent use of murder weapons. Iconic slasher villains typically have a signature weapon of choice, such as a chainsaw, machete, butcher knife, or razor claws. However, the killer frequently swaps out their gun in this film, replacing a machete with something as basic as a bag of rocks. This inconsistency becomes even more absurd with the killer's reveal, casting doubt on earlier killings.

Worth Watching?

Slasher fans tend to be more forgiving and accepting of lower-tier horror films. As long as the essential elements are present, they can find enjoyment in a B-level effort. Pillow Party Massacre comes close to fulfilling its premise but falls slightly short, needing more impact to be a compelling slasher film.

Pillow Party Massacre Review (2023) Worth Watching? - ALL HORROR Tweet it

Would it Kill You to Subscribe?

Get horror news, reviews and movie recommendations every Friday!

We respect your email privacy